Single mother Sabrina Gervais has built a happy life with her daughter Charlotte in their eastern Long Island hometown of Holly Point. Having Charlie meant putting some of her own dreams on hold, but Sabrina is content to surround herself with family and friends, safe from the realities of the outside world. She had enough of that when the man she loved broke her heart. Jake Killen's career in professional hockey has brought him many rewards on and off the ice, but returning to New York brings back a flood of memories. When he sees Sabrina again, he discovers that he didn't just move away from her ten years ago, but also from their unborn child. Struggling with anger, guilt, and chemistry that's off the chart, Sabrina and Jake wonder if they can find love again and, this Christmas, make all their wishes come true.