Officer Chad Charming absolutely does not believe in love at first sight, or even love at all. Apple Grove is famous for their Fairy Tale Parade, and Chad is working when a horse carrying the parade's Prince Charming kicks him, landing him in the hospital.
Jeff Garner's family has a history of love at first sight and the local high school drama teacher is mortified when his horse kicks the sexiest man he's ever seen. One look and he knows Chad's the man for him.
Jeff sets out to woo the man, even though Chad makes it clear he isn't looking for a relationship. While Chad recovers from his injuries, the two become close, but can Chad ever get past the idea love isn't real and allow himself to love his very own Prince Charming?