Adair is perfect — beautiful, intelligent, and a talented actor and singer, he's the star of Hawk Eye Theater Troupe.

Quiet and shy, Finely excels at making something out of nothing. A talented costume designer, he longs to share the spotlight with Adair, but he knows he has neither the talent nor the charisma to make the transition from backstage production to leading man — until he finds a pair of magical shoes left by a mysterious benefactor.

Thanks to his newfound magic, Finley's life starts to turn around. Everything he wasn't, he becomes. Everything he wanted, he receives. But the closer they get to show time, the more Finley questions if the love he wants for Adair ends on stage or if what they've found can survive once the curtain falls and the magic goes back in the box.