Phoebe's in a losing battle with a crying child she's taking care of. That is until her savior, her neighbor Jackson, appears. He's unexpectedly good at taking care of children, even though he looks like a menacing pirate. Whenever he looks at her, Phoebe's heart races. When the landlady misinterprets the situation, Jackson blurts out that they're engaged. Suddenly Pheobe finds herself living with this man she can't resist!